In both aircraft and cruise-ship manufacturing, there’s a debate: is bigger always better? In aviation, the largest commercial plane, the Airbus A380, is popular only with airlines, notably Emirates, that are staking the future on carrying a lot of people over long distances to and from big airports.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/99f0f/99f0f25e82a21c01986b10a00a13889a7ffde809" alt=""
With cruise ships, there has been greater investment by those who believe bigger is better, although niche operators beg to differ.